The best way to choose a custom home builder is to ask how they price the house, then check that answer against their contract, their license and their past clients. Style and photos matter, but most custom home horror stories start with a price that wasn't really a price. If a builder can tell you exactly what's fixed, what's an allowance, and how changes get priced, you're talking to someone who has done this before.
Updated November 2026
We're Elk Ridge Custom Homes, a design-build firm in Colorado Springs. We've been building fully custom homes here since 2003, so yes, we'd like you to pick us. But the questions below are the same ones we'd tell a friend to ask any builder, us included.
Start with how they price the house
There are two common ways custom builders charge for a home, and the difference shapes everything that follows.
| Fixed price | Cost-plus | |
|---|---|---|
| How it works | You agree on one price for the whole house before construction starts | You pay the actual cost of labor and materials, plus the builder's fee or percentage |
| When you know the total | Before you sign the build contract | When the house is finished |
| Who carries the risk of overruns | Mostly the builder | Mostly you |
| What to watch for | How many items are allowances, and how big they are | Whether there's a cap, and how the builder's fee is calculated |
Neither one is automatically good or bad. Cost-plus can work with a builder you trust and a budget with room in it. But if you need to hit a number, ask for a fixed price, and ask what has to happen before the builder can give you one. A real fixed price needs finished plans, engineering, every selection made and actual bids from subcontractors. A "fixed price" built on a per-square-foot guess isn't fixed.
Even with a fixed price, a few things usually can't be priced exactly until digging starts, like excavation and foundation work. Those should be listed as allowances with a realistic number next to each one. A long list of small allowances is a warning sign, because every one of them can move.
Questions to ask every builder
Pricing and contracts
- Is your price fixed or cost-plus? If it's fixed, when do I get it?
- What's listed as an allowance, and how did you set each number?
- How are change orders priced, and do I approve them in writing before the work happens?
- What does your design phase cost, and do I keep the plans if I don't build with you?
Experience and capacity
- How many homes do you build a year, and how many are going right now?
- Who is my day-to-day contact, and how often will I hear from them?
- Have you built on a lot like mine, with a well, septic, a slope or a long driveway?
- Can I walk a home you're building now, not just a finished one?
Paperwork worth checking
- Their license number. In Colorado Springs and El Paso County, builders are licensed by the Pikes Peak Regional Building Department. Colorado has no statewide general contractor license, so the local license is the one that counts.
- A current certificate of insurance for general liability and workers' compensation.
- Lien waivers. Ask whether the builder collects them from subcontractors and suppliers as they're paid. If you have a construction loan, most banks require them. In Colorado, an unpaid sub or supplier can file a lien on your property up to four months after their last work, even if you've already paid the builder.
- The warranty in writing: what it covers, for how long, and how you request service.
References
Ask for two or three clients who finished in the last couple of years. Skip "were you happy?" and ask what actually predicts your experience:
- Did the final cost land close to the contract price?
- How were changes and surprises handled?
- Did you always know who to call, and did they call back?
- Would you build with them again?
Red flags
- A price per square foot offered as a quote before there are plans. It's a starting point for conversation, not a number to budget around.
- Pressure to sign the build contract before the design is finished.
- A long list of allowances, or allowances set low enough to make the total look good.
- Vague answers about who will run your job, or a different answer every time you ask.
- No license number, or an insurance certificate that's "coming."
- Reluctance to let you talk to recent clients or visit a home under construction.
How we answer these at Elk Ridge
Since we're asking you to put builders to this test, here are our own answers.
| Question | Our answer |
|---|---|
| Fixed price or cost-plus? | Fixed price, set at the end of our design phase, before you sign a build contract |
| What's an allowance? | Mainly excavation and foundation, which can't be priced exactly until we dig. Our cost guide explains how those work |
| Change orders | Priced and approved by you in writing before the work happens |
| Design phase cost | $30,000 to $40,000 for design and estimation, depending on the size of the home. You keep the plans either way |
| Homes per year | 6 to 10. We stay small on purpose so you know Phil and Jason personally. During construction, our project manager and coordinators are your day-to-day contacts, and Phil and Jason are always available |
| Timeline | About 3 to 4 months for design and estimation, then 8 to 12 months of construction |
| Lien waivers | Collected from subcontractors and suppliers as they're paid, and provided to your construction lender |
| What's standard | Closed-cell spray foam insulation, solid wood trim and doors, commercial-grade appliances and more. Our build standards list it line by line |
| Warranty | Two years, written into the build contract |
| Lot evaluation | We'll help you evaluate a lot before you buy it |
If you're still deciding between hiring an architect first and going design-build, our guide to design-build vs. hiring an architect compares the two. Our process page walks through every step.
Frequently asked questions
How many builders should I talk to?
Two or three is usually enough. More than that and the conversations start to blur. Ask each one the same questions so you can compare answers side by side.
Should I pick the builder with the lowest bid?
Not on price alone. Compare what's included, how many allowances there are and how big they are. A lower number with larger allowances often ends up costing more.
Is a fixed price really fixed?
It should be, for everything in the contract. What changes it is what you change: new selections or design changes after you sign. Ask how those are priced before you start.
Do I need a lot before I talk to a builder?
No. A good builder can help you evaluate a lot before you buy it, including utilities, wells, septic and how the slope affects the foundation.
How do I check a builder's license in Colorado Springs?
Ask for their license number and confirm it with the Pikes Peak Regional Building Department, which licenses builders in Colorado Springs and El Paso County.
Want to put us through the test?
Call Phil or Jason at 719-428-5140, or reach out here. Bring your questions, your lot if you have one, and any plans or photos you've been saving. We'll give you straight answers, even if it turns out we're not the right fit.
Written by Phil Jung
